Saturday, March 22, 2014

China's Xi starts first Europe tour

Chinese President Xi Jinping begins key Europe visit

Chinese President Xi Jinping and his wife Peng Liyuan  at Ngurah Rai Airport in Denpasar, Bali on October 5, 2013 Xi Jinping (L) and his wife Peng Liyuan (R) are being joined by 200 trade delegates

Chinese President Xi Jinping is due to land in the Netherlands later for his first trip to Europe as leader.

His tour will include France, Germany and Belgium as well as the headquarters of the EU in Brussels.

A 200-strong business delegation will join him on a trip that is expected to be dominated by trade - possibly including an order for 150 Airbus jets.

Mr Xi is also likely to face pressure from Western powers to be firmer with Russia over its actions in Ukraine.

China usually supports Russia in foreign-policy issues, but last week declined to fully back its ally over Ukraine.

Beijing abstained from a vote at the UN that would have condemned Russia's takeover of Ukraine's Crimea region.

The BBC's John Sudworth in Shanghai says Europe and China have a relationship often marred by friction.

A tit-for-tat trade dispute, with China targeting French wine after the EU imposed tariffs on Chinese solar panels, was only resolved on Friday.

US first lady Michelle Obama and her daughters Malia (right) and Sasha is greeted by Chinese President Xi Jinping and his wife Peng Liyuan at the Diaoyutai State guest house in Beijing (21 March 2014) President Xi on Friday welcomed Michelle Obama and her two daughters to Beijing

Mr Xi will be welcomed by Dutch King Willem-Alexander and Queen Maxima at the start of his state visit to the Netherlands.

He arrives in advance of a G7 meeting on the sidelines of the Nuclear Security Summit (NSS) in The Hague next week.

Mr Xi is expected to discuss the situation in Ukraine with President Obama on the sidelines of the summit.

Correspondents say the Chinese president is likely to repeat Beijing's call for "calm and restraint" in the crisis.

The Chinese leader will also meet French President Francois Hollande and German Chancellor Angela Merkel on his trip, which ends in Belgium on 1 April.

One side issue of note from the visit comes from reports in the German press suggesting that the Chinese delegation had asked for an official visit, accompanied by Chancellor Merkel, to a Holocaust memorial.

Berlin is said to have refused, fearing that it would be used by China as propaganda to highlight its complaint that Japan has not done enough to atone for its militaristic past.

Der Spiegel reports that the Chinese delegation has been told that President Xi is free to visit memorials in his own time.


Man in court over McConville murder

Jean McConville: Ivor Bell in court over Disappeared charge

Jean McConville and family Widow Jean McConville left behind 10 children

An alleged former senior IRA member is due in court charged with aiding and abetting the murder of Jean McConville.

The Belfast mother-of-10 was taken from her flat by the IRA in December 1972.

Ivor Bell, 77, alleged to have been a senior member in the Provisional IRA in the 1970s, was arrested at his home in Andersontown, west Belfast, on Tuesday.

He is expected to appear before magistrates in Belfast on Saturday accused of aiding and abetting murder as well as membership of the IRA.

Mrs McConville, 37, became known as one of the Disappeared.

She was kidnapped in front of her children after being accused of having been an informer - a claim that was later dismissed following an official investigation by the Northern Ireland Police Ombudsman

Ivor Bell is due to appear in court on Saturday Ivor Bell is due to appear in court on Saturday

She was held at one or more houses before being shot and buried in secret. Her body was eventually recovered on a beach in County Louth in August 2003.

Nobody has ever been charged with her murder.

The Disappeared are those who were abducted, murdered and secretly buried by republicans during the Troubles.

The IRA admitted in 1999 that it murdered and buried at secret locations nine of the Disappeared.

The Independent Commission for the Location of Victims' Remains was established in 1999 by a treaty between the British and Irish governments.

It lists 16 people as "disappeared". Despite extensive searches, the remains of seven of them have not been found.

Mr Bell was part of an IRA delegation, which also included Sinn Féin's Gerry Adams and Martin McGuinness, that held secret talks with the British government in London in 1972.


Lamont claims SNP fails on equality

Labour's Johann Lamont claims SNP fails on equality

Johann Lamont Johann Lamont will criticise the Scottish government - and pledge to make high earners pay more tax

Scotland's Labour leader will compare Holyrood's SNP government to the Tories, saying it has failed to deliver equality.

Johann Lamont will tell her party's conference that, despite seven years in power, Scottish ministers had failed to distribute wealth from rich to poor.

Branding the Scottish government "Osborne Max", she will pledge to ensure the rich pay their fair share.

Ms Lamont's speech comes ahead of the Scottish independence referendum.

On 18 September, voters in Scotland will be asked the Yes/No question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

Ms Lamont will tell delegates in Perth: "Seven years of nationalism in Scotland - and not one policy which distributes wealth from rich to poor - in fact the opposite.

"Those in the richest houses saving most. Those with the most getting more. Those with the least getting less.

"That isn't just a betrayal of social justice - it is a betrayal of everything we believe Scotland stands for."

The Scottish Labour leader will urge members of the party faithful to "look beyond the saltire and plaid", to what she argued the SNP planned to deliver.

"While we will ask the rich to pay their fair share - the nationalists tell us that would put Scotland at a disadvantage," Ms Lamont will say.

"Social injustice is what puts Scotland at its greatest disadvantage and restoring the 50p tax rate will start to fight injustice.

"We have a nationalist government which refuses to reverse Tory tax cuts for millionaires - and a nationalist government which votes against giving workers on government contracts the living wage."

She will tell the conference: "Forget the talk of indy lite - this nationalist government is Osborne Max."


Malaysia plane search in third week

MH370 Malaysia plane: Search enters third week

No debris found on second search day, as Jon Donnison reports

The search for the missing Malaysia Airlines plane has now entered its third week, with rescue teams scouring remote seas in the Indian Ocean.

Satellites detected debris two days ago some 2,500 km (1,550 miles) south-west of the Australian city of Perth, but nothing has yet been found.

Flight MH370 dropped out of contact an hour after leaving Kuala Lumpur en route to Beijing on 8 March.

Malaysian officials suspect the plane was deliberately taken off course.

Five aircraft have been scouring a 23,000 sq km area of rough seas in the southern Indian Ocean.

Additional vessels supplied by China, Japan and the United Kingdom are due to join them in the search.

"It's about the most inaccessible spot that you can imagine on the face of the Earth, but if there is anything down there, we will find it," said Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott.

"We owe it to the families and the friends and the loved ones of [those on board] to do everything we can to try to resolve what is as yet an extraordinary riddle."

'Visual search'

Three Australian air force P-3 Orion planes, a US Navy P-8 Poseidon and a civil Bombardier Global Express jet have been taking part in the last two days of searching.

Each aircraft is able to search for no more than two hours due to the distance from land.

Amsa image Australian authorities said one of the objects on the satellite images was 24m in size
Amsa image The objects were seen on satellite images dated 16 March and assessed by experts

Bad weather on Thursday hampered the search using radar so on Friday the planes flew below cloud cover for a "visual search".

John Young of the Australian Maritime Safety Authority (Amsa) said they were "flying relatively low" with "very highly skilled and trained observers looking out of the aircraft windows... to see objects".

But Amsa said Friday's search had concluded "without any sightings".

Two merchant ships have joined the search and the Australian navy ship, HMAS Success, is on its way.

China - which had 153 of its citizens on board flight MH370 - is sending three navy vessels as well as its icebreaker Xue Long (Snow Dragon).

'Long haul'

The search effort in the southern Indian Ocean is only part of a much wider hunt for the plane - reaching as far north as Kazakhstan.

Satellite data, picked up some seven hours after the plane lost radio contact, suggests it could have disappeared in two corridors to the north and south of its last known location in the Malacca Straits.

Map showing search area for MH370

Malaysia's Acting Transport Minister Hishammuddin Hussein thanked the 20 or so countries involved in the search and said they were facing a "long haul".

But he acknowledged they are working against the clock, as they now have two weeks left to locate the plane's "black box" voice and data recorder before it no longer transmits an electronic locator signal.

Malaysian officials say they believe the plane was intentionally diverted as it turned back on itself - heading towards the Malacca Straits - after its communications were cut.

Correspondents say many families are hoping the objects seen in the Indian Ocean are not debris from the plane, as they are holding on to hope that their relatives could be alive somewhere.

Wen Wancheng, whose 33-year-old son Wen Yongsheng was on the plane, said: "What wreckage? In a few days they are going to say it's not true.

"[The Malaysian authorities] need to stop giving us false information. I simply don't believe them any more."

Amsa map of search area for 21 March

Lamont claims SNP fails on equality

Labour's Johann Lamont claims SNP fails on equality

Johann Lamont Johann Lamont will criticise the Scottish government - and pledge to make high earners pay more tax

Scotland's Labour leader will compare Holyrood's SNP government to the Tories, saying it has failed to deliver equality.

Johann Lamont will tell her party's conference that, despite seven years in power, Scottish ministers had failed to distribute wealth from rich to poor.

Branding the Scottish government "Osborne Max", she will pledge to ensure the rich pay their fair share.

Ms Lamont's speech comes ahead of the Scottish independence referendum.

On 18 September, voters in Scotland will be asked the Yes/No question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

Ms Lamont will tell delegates in Perth: "Seven years of nationalism in Scotland - and not one policy which distributes wealth from rich to poor - in fact the opposite.

"Those in the richest houses saving most. Those with the most getting more. Those with the least getting less.

"That isn't just a betrayal of social justice - it is a betrayal of everything we believe Scotland stands for."

The Scottish Labour leader will urge members of the party faithful to "look beyond the saltire and plaid", to what she argued the SNP planned to deliver.

"While we will ask the rich to pay their fair share - the nationalists tell us that would put Scotland at a disadvantage," Ms Lamont will say.

"Social injustice is what puts Scotland at its greatest disadvantage and restoring the 50p tax rate will start to fight injustice.

"We have a nationalist government which refuses to reverse Tory tax cuts for millionaires - and a nationalist government which votes against giving workers on government contracts the living wage."

She will tell the conference: "Forget the talk of indy lite - this nationalist government is Osborne Max."


Labour 'supports pension reforms'

Labour will support pension reforms, says Rachel Reeves

Shadow work and pensions secretary Rachel Reeves Labour's Rachel Reeves said she wanted more detail about the pension reforms

Labour will support government plans to overhaul pensions, the shadow work and pensions secretary has said.

Rachel Reeves told BBC Radio 4's Any Questions she supports the changes announced in Wednesday's Budget.

But she said much more detail was needed about what the changes would mean "in practice".

The proposed reforms will allow people to spend their pension pots how they wish rather having to buy an annuity, which guarantees an annual income.

The new rules are due to come in from April 2015, subject to consultation, with some existing regulations to be relaxed from next Thursday.

'More flexibility'

Speaking to Any Questions, Ms Reeves said the annuities and pension market currently "does not work well for people who have saved all their lives".

She said: "I support reform and I support what has been announced this week, although we need to see a lot more detail about what that will mean in practice."

The party wants the consultation to consider whether the move helps lower and middle income taxpayers, whether people who want to buy an annuity under the current system can do so, and what provision is made for advice.

Ms Reeves said "wider reform", including a cap on pension providers' fees and charges, was needed.

Asked to give an undertaking that Labour would not seek to overturn the reform, she added: "I don't think the annuities market works for people at the moment, so I support reform and I support the changes that people have more flexibility about how to access their money. I can give that assurance."

She said she believes "the majority of people" would not choose to draw down their full pension.

'Complex proposals'

Labour leader Ed Miliband earlier insisted he backs more flexible rules on pensions, but said his party wanted to look at the detail before they support the changes in Parliament.

"We're certainly not going to reject these proposals out of hand," said Mr Miliband. "That would be the wrong thing to do.

"These are complex proposals. We need to scrutinise the detail and we need to have some clear answers from the government on some of those questions."

It is expected that anyone over the age of 55 who belongs to a private pension scheme (as opposed to a final-salary scheme) will be able to take out their savings as a lump sum to spend or invest as they wish.

Chancellor George Osborne has dismissed fears newly-retired people could "blow" their money.

A Downing Street spokesman earlier said that under the rule changes, pensioners were guaranteed independent advice before making any decision about their pension provision.


Burundi 'joggers' jailed for life

Burundi MSD opposition 'joggers' get life sentences

MSD leader Alexis Sinduhije addressing a crowd in Burundi on 11 April 2010 MSD leader Alexis Sinduhije (pictured in 2010) has been charged over the clashes but has not been caught

A court in Burundi has sentenced 21 opposition supporters to life in prison for participating in an illegal demonstration that turned violent.

Another 26 Movement for Solidarity and Democracy (MSD) supporters were given shorter jail terms.

They denied participating in a march and say they were out jogging when a police crackdown began.

Meanwhile, a government attempt to change the constitution has failed to gain enough parliamentary support.

Opposition parties boycotted the session as they felt the amendments would have undermined reconciliation agreements that ended the country's long ethnic-based civil war in which some 300,000 people died.

The government wanted to create a post of prime minister and reduce the role of the senate in overseeing the ethnic balance in state institutions but it fell one vote short of the required 80% majority.

The BBC's Prime Ndikumagenge in the capital, Bujumbura, says the government's proposals have been partly to blame for the recent rise in political tensions in the small East African nation.

'Insurrection'
Map

In Burundi, permission must be sought from the authorities to hold a political march or public gathering.

Police say that on Saturday 8 March, they had intelligence that sporting activities were going to be used as a front to organise illegal demonstrations.

Officers were deployed in the city to prevent this happening.

But the situation deteriorated into clashes and some of the joggers tried to seek refuge in the MSD headquarters, taking two policemen hostage.

Several people were injured in the fracas and afterwards about 70 MSD supporters were arrested, with 48 facing life sentences for insurrection.

The authorities have since restricted jogging clubs to certain areas.

All sports must now take place in nine parks in Bujumbura and other designated football pitches, it was announced earlier this week.

Our correspondent says jogging is a national pastime, with hundreds of people out running or taking a walk on weekend mornings.

MSD leader Alexis Sinduhije was also charged over the clashes, but has not been caught.

Those found guilty on Friday are to appeal against their sentences.

The court in Bujumbura also acquitted 22 of defendants.

Presidential elections in Burundi, one of the world's poorest countries, are due next year - they will be the third since the official end to the conflict.

Under a series of peace deals, up to 40% of posts in various state institutions, including parliament, are reserved for members of the minority Tutsi community.

Laws currently need a two-thirds majority to be passed but the constitutional changes would have changed this to a simple majority, effectively removing the Tutsi blocking veto.


Thousands join rare Algeria rally

Thousands join rare Algeria rally

Algerians attend the gathering organised by opposition political parties calling for a boycott of presidential elections on 17 April Rival Islamist and secular party opposition supporters attended Friday's rally

Thousands of Algerian opposition supporters have called for a boycott of next month's presidential election, during an unprecedented mass rally.

Islamist and secular opposition parties at the rally denounced 77-year-old President Abdelaziz Bouteflika's attempt to win a fourth term of office.

They say a stroke last year has left him unfit to govern.

Mr Bouteflika, in power since 1999, scrapped constitutional rules in 2008 limiting him to two terms in office.

He has rarely been seen in public in recent months, but correspondents say the backing of the governing National Liberation Front (FLN), army factions and business elites almost guarantees him election victory.

'The real Algeria'

Chanting "boycott" and "the people want the regime out" about 5,000 people packed into the sports stadium where various opposition leaders denounced Mr Bouteflika's re-election bid and demanded reforms to a political system they see as corrupt.

Algerians attend a gathering organised by political parties calling for the boycott of the 17 April presidential elections About 5,000 people packed into an Algiers sports stadium
A protester holds up a sign at the rally on 21 March calling for the boycott of the Algerian presidential election Some earlier small protests against Mr Bouteflika's re-election bid were swiftly quashed by security forces
An Algerian man leaves after attending a gathering organised by political parties calling for the boycott of the 17 April presidential elections Friday's rally is believed to be one of the biggest in Algeria in recent months

Large opposition gatherings are unusual in Algeria, where FLN elites and army generals have dominated politics since independence from France in 1962.

"The people here are the people who have been excluded, who have been put aside, but this is the real Algeria," Rally for Culture and Democracy (RCD) party spokesman Mohsen Belabes told cheering crowds.

"The regime will collapse, but Algeria will survive."

Correspondents say Mr Bouteflika ordered heavy spending from Algeria's oil earnings on housing, public services and infrastructure projects to offset social unrest after the Arab Spring uprisings across North Africa in 2011.

But the parties within the opposition are not united and remain weak, analysts say.

Evidence of this disunity was evident at Friday's rally, where rival Islamist and secular supporters heckled and taunted at each other across the stadium.

The president is one of the few remaining veterans of the war of independence against France.

But he has had persistent health problems and his rule has recently been dogged by corruption scandals implicating members of his inner circle.


Ex-IRA man faces Disappeared charge

Jean McConville: Ivor Bell charged in connection with murder

Jean McConville and family Widow Jean McConville left behind 10 children when she was abducted and murdered

A former IRA leader has been charged in connection with the abduction and murder of Jean McConville.

The Belfast mother-of-10 was taken by the IRA from her flat in December 1972.

Ivor Bell, 77, who was a senior leader in the Provisional IRA in the 1970s, was arrested at his home in Andersonstown on Tuesday.

He has been charged with aiding and abetting murder and membership of the IRA. He is expected to appear in court on Saturday.

Ivor Bell is due to appear in court on Saturday Ivor Bell is due to appear in court on Saturday

Ivor Bell was part of an IRA delegation that held secret talks with the British government in London in 1972.

Among the delegation were Sinn Féin's Gerry Adams and Martin McGuinness.

Jean McConville, 37, became known as one of the Disappeared.

She was kidnapped in front of her children and accused of having been an informer. That claim was later dismissed following an official investigation.

She was held at one or more houses before being shot. Her body was recovered on a beach in County Louth in August 2003.

The Disappeared are those who were abducted, murdered and secretly buried by republicans during the Troubles.

The IRA admitted in 1999 that it murdered and buried at secret locations nine of the Disappeared.

The Independent Commission for the Location of Victims' Remains was established in 1999 by a treaty between the British and Irish governments.

It lists 16 people as "disappeared". Despite extensive searches, the remains of seven of them have not been found.


Stop doing evil, Pope tells mafia

Pope Francis denounces 'evil, blood-stained' mafia

Pope Francis after leading an audience with the family members of victims of the mafia at the San Gregorio VII church in Rome (21 March 2014) The pope was uncompromising in his criticism of the mafia as he met family members bereaved by organised crime

Pope Francis has launched a stinging attack on the mafia, warning gangsters that they will go to hell unless they repent and stop doing evil.

"Blood-stained money, blood-stained power, you can't bring it with you to your next life. Repent," he said.

He was speaking at a prayer vigil for relatives of those killed by the mafia.

The Pope has spoken out frequently about the evils of corruption and wrote a booklet on the subject in 2005 when he was archbishop of Buenos Aires.

'No joy'

The meeting near Rome on Friday - organised by a citizens' group called Libera - was aimed at demonstrating the Roman Catholic Church's opposition to organised crime, rejecting historic ties with mafia bosses claiming to be good Catholics.

Pope Francis (right) leaves the church in Rome with Father Luigi Ciotti of the Catholic Libera association The vigil is held every year, but this was the first time that it was attended by the pope
Pope Francis delivers his speech during a meeting with relatives of innocent mafia victims The pope told told Italy's mobsters to relinquish their 'blood-stained money' which 'cannot be taken into paradise'
Pope Francis greets the faithful as he leaves at the end of a meeting with relatives of innocent mafia victims More than 1,000 people attended prayers with the pope at a church near the Vatican
Pope Francis (centre right) attends the service The meeting was an attempt to draw a line under the church's historic ties with mafia dons claiming to be God-fearing Roman Catholics

The vigil was filled with those who have suffered at the hands of the mafia, including people whose family members and loved ones had been killed.

As the names of those murdered were read out, the Pope listened, deep in sombre thought, says he BBC's Alan Johnston in Rome.

After expressing solidarity with the 842 people at the vigil, he said that he could not leave the service without addressing those not present: The "protagonists" of mafia violence.

"This life that you live now won't give you pleasure. It won't give you joy or happiness," he said.

"There's still time to not end up in hell, which is what awaits you if you continue on this path."

Our correspondent says there is a long list of brave priests in Italy who have stood up to the mafia, and some have paid with lives.

But he says that the wider Church has been accused of not doing enough to confront the gangsters.

Anti-mafia activists hope that the Pope's words are a signal that he is on their side.


How maths helped find another lost plane

MH370 Malaysia plane: How maths helped find an earlier crash

Members of the Brazilian Frigate Constituicao recovering debris in June 2009 Members of the Brazilian Frigate Constituicao recovering debris in June 2009

Statisticians helped locate an Air France plane in 2011 which was missing for two years. Could mathematical techniques inspired by an 18th Century Presbyterian minister be used to locate the mysterious disappearance of Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370?

In June 2009, Air France flight 447 went missing flying from Rio de Janeiro in Brazil to Paris, France.

Debris from the Airbus A330 was found floating on the surface of the Atlantic five days later, but the mystery of why the plane crashed could only be answered by finding the black box and the cockpit voice recorder.

You may think that having found the debris it would be easy to find the rest of the plane, but it's not that simple - after a number of days, the material would have moved with the ocean current.

Software does exist that can simulate how the debris has travelled from the initial impact. It is used regularly by the US coast guard.

But in this case, because this area near the equator is known for unpredictable currents - particularly at that time of year - it was no help.

Debris from the Air France crash is laid out in a warehouse Debris from the Air France crash is laid out for investigation in 2009

American, Brazilian and French ships, planes and submarines all searched for the plane, but they couldn't find it.

At this point France's aviation accident investigation authority, BEA, made a call to a group of statisticians in the US who had expertise in finding objects lost at sea.

Senior analyst Colleen Keller flew to France to help.

"The French BEA had already done a wonderful job of coming up with different theories for why the aircraft might have crashed," she says.

They also had lots of data about historical crashes and the results of the searches that had already been carried out.

To turn all this information into numbers and probability, Keller and her team from Metron Inc in Virginia, relied on Bayesian statistics named after a British Presbyterian minister called Thomas Bayes.

This type of thinking allows you to assess various scenarios at once - even contradictory ones. The probability of each being true is brought together to give you the most likely solution. And if you find new information, you can revise your model easily.

Keller and her colleagues went through all the available information and assessed the uncertainties of each piece of data - applying Bayesian principles of probability to work out the most likely location of the plane.

The team split up the search area into a grid, and applied to each cell a figure representing the probability that the plane would be found there.

A small Brazilian Air Force radar plane prepares to leave an airport strip in front of a green, rocky, hill A Brazilian Air Force radar plane prepares to leave Fernando de Noronha airport to search for Flight 447

To calculate these figures, they first looked at the theories about what caused the plane to crash. For instance, they assessed the likeliness of various mechanical failures, and came up with a probability for each scenario.

They then assessed historical data from previous crashes, noting, for example, that planes were usually found very close to where they were last known to have been.

Finally, Keller and her team lowered the probability of the plane being found in locations that had already been searched.

"There are two components to Bayesian maths which make it unique. It allows you to consider all the data you have including the uncertainties which is very important because nothing is certain," says Keller.

"And to combine it all - it even allows you to combine views that contradict each other.

"For instance with the Malaysian search, you have that arc to the north and the arc to the south. It's either one or the other but it can't have gone both ways, but [Bayes] allows you to preserve all your theories and weight them."

The second benefit is that the Bayesian approach is very flexible, Keller says. It allows you to update your body of knowledge at any time. If something new comes up, you factor it in and update the probability map.

A Meteosat-9 infrared satellite image  shows weather conditions over Atlantic A 2009 infrared satellite image shows weather conditions off the Brazilian coast and the plane search area

In the case of the Air France plane, they could be sure that the plane had come down within a 40-mile radius of the last location pinged out by its on-board computer system.

Yet this area was so huge that the investigators were struggling to know where to look.

The probability map Keller provided gave, by contrast, a much tighter area to search.

A team went out there, hoping that finally the mystery would be solved. But those hopes were dashed. There was no sign of the plane.

It seemed the statisticians could not help after all.

Some months later, though, Air France got back in touch and asked Keller to make one last attempt to analyse the data.

This time, she and her colleagues decided they were not happy with one of their initial assumptions.

The historical data showed that after a crash, the black box will be emitting a signal in 90% of cases.

In the immediate aftermath of the crash, search teams had spent a lot of time sweeping the areas close to the last known location, listening for the ping of the black box or voice recorder.

They had heard nothing. So Keller and her team had decided there was a very low probability the plane would be found there.

But what if neither the black box nor the voice recorder were sending a signal?

Alain Bouillard, investigator-in-charge of flight Air France 447 safety investigation from French agency Bureau of Enquiry and Analysis for Civil Aviation Safety (BEA), speaks during a press conference focused on the AF447 Rio-Paris plane flight black boxes (screen), on May 12, 2011 Alain Bouillard of the BEA speaking about the Air France 447 black boxes, found in 2011

The Metron statisticians now adapted their model to this possible scenario and came up with a new area of highest probability.

A team returned to the scene to look - and this time they found the plane.

The mystery of the crash was solved. The black box and voice recorder data appear to show that the pilots were given faulty speed readings, responded inappropriately, and lost control of the plane.

"It still was a minor miracle that we found it," says Keller.

"It was lucky that the wreckage was on the bottom of the ocean floor, on a very sandy area. There were some areas down there that looked like the Himalayas - in terms of mountains, crags, and valleys."

If the plane had been in one of those areas, she says, "it could have been undetected forever".

Keller says she is not sure Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 will be found.

"It's a big world out there. And I know people are saying - how could you possibly hide or not find a Boeing 777?

"[But] it's very likely if we don't get any breakthroughs, it's at the bottom of the Indian Ocean and we will never find it, sadly."

Even finding debris might not mean finding the bulk of the plane.

"If we found wreckage at this point, it would tell us it was in one body of water rather than the other," Keller says. "But it's so long since the plane would have crashed that I don't think the wreckage is going to be very helpful."

Follow @BBCNewsMagazine on Twitter and on Facebook


The footballer who disappeared

Joe Gaetjens - the footballer who disappeared

Joe Gaetjens after the match

One of the biggest shocks in World Cup history happened in 1950, when the US beat England, thanks to a goal scored by Haitian Joe Gaetjens. Years later, after Gaetjens returned to Haiti, he was killed - possibly by the president himself.

Joe Gaetjens made his name on 29 June 1950. "Out of nowhere apparently, my father came and went head first and hit the ball hard enough to change its direction - so the goalie from the England team was going one way and the ball went the other way," says his eldest son Lesly.

The 15,000 football fans in Brazil's Belo Horizonte stadium went wild - moments earlier they thought the US didn't have even the slightest chance of beating England. Even the US coach had described his side as sheep ready to be slaughtered.

While the England players were professionals, the Americans were part-timers - one was a teacher, another drove a hearse for a living and Gaetjens was an accountancy student.

Jo Gaetjens, Paris 1951-52

He was born in the Haitian capital, Port-au-Prince, in 1924 to a relatively well-off family. He loved football and by the age of 14 was signed up to the Etoile Haitienne team where he became known for his goal-scoring headers.

But his parents felt he couldn't rely on a football career to make a living, so in 1947 they sent him to New York's Columbia University.

While he was there, he took a job washing dishes in a restaurant - partly for the money but mostly because the owner also owned the Brookhattan soccer team. Gaetjens was their star striker and he soon came to the attention of the US national coaches.

"During those days, as long as you were willing to sign a paper saying that you will become a citizen of the United States then you will be included on the team," says Lesly.

Gaetjens was included in the World Cup line-up and was sent to Brazil where the US team faced England.

When one of his team-mates took a shot at the goal, Gaetjens was ready to finish it off. There's no footage of the winning goal - most of the cameras were at the other end of the pitch where they expected the action to take place.

Back home, his family didn't even know he was in the team until they heard he had scored on the radio. The glory didn't last though - the US lost their next game and were eliminated.

In the end, Gaetjens decided not to take US citizenship and pursued his football career in France where he spent two relatively unsuccessful seasons. By 1954 he had returned home to Haiti.

Gaetjens (centre) in New York Joe Gaetjens (centre) with friends in New York

"In Haiti everybody was happy and partying - apparently all the players from all the teams gathered at the airport to receive him - it was like a national holiday kind of thing," says Lesly.

Injury soon brought Gaetjens' playing career to an end but he became a successful coach, helped young people get involved in soccer and also ran a chain of dry-cleaners. He married Liliane Defay and the couple had three children.

"The thing that I really think a lot about is the fact that he never had money in his pocket because he gave it all away to people that were in need... he loved his family and he really wanted to help Haiti," says Lesly.

"I remember seeing him play and I remember kicking a soccer ball with him before the games... I remember planting trees - he loved planting all kinds of fruit trees at the house."

But these were politically troubled times. In 1957, Francois "Papa Doc" Duvalier was elected president. He set about consolidating power by force, establishing his own personal militia to target rivals - the Tontons Macoutes took their name from the Haitian slang for bogeymen.

It's estimated that around 30,000 people were killed during Duvalier's 14-year rule as he brutally stamped out opposition. In 1964, against a backdrop of fear and paranoia, Duvalier declared himself president for life.

Gaetjens was not politically active but others in his family were agitating for change. Two of his brothers, Jean and Freddie had gone to neighbouring Dominican Republic where they were involved in a scheme to overthrow Duvalier.

Francois Duvalier, 1969 Francois Duvalier, 1969

Their plans were never realised but the Gaetjens name was brought to Duvalier's attention. "In those days, Duvalier would go after the whole family and is known to have killed entire families of people that went against him," says Lesly.

Gaetjens didn't realise the danger he was in until it was too late. On 8 July 1964, when Lesly was seven, "they sent two Tontons Macoutes to one of my father's dry cleaning [shops]… when he approached, the Tontons Macoutes got [him] in the back of the car and put a gun to his head. Then he disappeared."

His wife, Liliane did everything she could to find him but people were too scared to help or ask questions. All she managed to find out was that he had been taken to Fort Dimanche, a prison notorious for torture.

She and the children stayed in Haiti, living in fear, until 1966. In January that year, they boarded a plane to Puerto Rico pretending they were going on holiday - in fact they were going into exile to start a new life.

For years they lived in hope that Gaetjens was alive, only receiving official confirmation of his death in 1972 - the year after Duvalier died.

It's not known exactly how or when he was killed but over time the family managed to piece together fragments of information.

"The version that I hear the most is that Duvalier himself went that night to Fort Dimanche… and he himself killed my dad," says Lesly. He adds that he has a CIA document confirming that both men were at the prison that night.

After Duvalier's death in 1971, his son Jean-Claude, known as Baby Doc, took over the presidency and ruled until 1986 when he fled the country amid popular discontent.

Since then Haiti has faced coups, corruption and natural disasters - the 2010 earthquake killed more than 250,000 people. One hundred and fifty thousand are still living in temporary accommodation.

Lesly lives in the US but has visited Haiti and written a book about his father. "I sometimes think that they could even make a movie," he says.

"Not so much about the goal because that was one moment but a movie about all the things that happened before and after... it's still the poorest country in the western hemisphere and people are still in misery."

Lesly Gaetjens spoke to Whistledown Productions for the BBC World Service programme Sporting Witness. Listen via BBC iPlayer Radio from 16:30 GMT or browse the Sporting Witness podcast archive.

Follow @BBCNewsMagazine on Twitter and on Facebook


The impact of sanctions on Russia

The impact of economic sanctions on Russia

 
Russian banknotes The Russian stock market and rouble have fallen

The US and EU have imposed economic sanctions on Russia over its annexation of Crimea from Ukraine.

The Russian stock market and rouble have fallen and two of the major ratings companies have downgraded Russia's credit outlook and growth forecasts for the year.

Do sanctions work?

A long-term study published by the Petersen Institute finds that economic sanctions are partially successful about one-third of the time.

Of the 174 cases that they examined dating from World War One, the most successful cases were when the goal was modest, such as the release of a political prisoner, where there was 50% success.

When the aim was more ambitious, such as changing a major policy, the success rate drops to about 30%.

For instance, US economic sanctions against Cuba since the 1960s were largely judged as a failure as the embargo hurt the living standards of the people in that country with no discernible effect on regime change.

But more recently, the sanctions against Iran - that included blockades of oil and overseas bank accounts - helped push the Iranians towards the negotiating table to agree to inspections of their nuclear programme.

The Iranian economy had suffered from the sanctions imposed in 2012. GDP fell by nearly 6% last year and inflation hit double digits, averaging some 39%.

The sanctions imposed on Russia are targeted at freezing assets and imposing travel bans on key Putin allies. Russia is imposing like-for-like sanctions in return.

The next question is whether there will be large-scale economic sanctions against Russia?

Some investors are not waiting to find out. The ratings company S&P estimates that $60bn (£36bn) left the country in the first three months of the year, which is nearly as much as the entire outflow from last year.

The other thing about such economic sanctions is that they will often harm those who impose them.

In the Iranian case, oil prices rose in the aftermath of the 2012 embargo, topping $110 per barrel.

It forced European refiners, who imported about half a million barrels a day, to seek alternatives, for instance.

As I have written about before, given that Russia is the largest energy supplier to Europe and is also one of the top three oil producers in the world, there will be broader economic consequences and not just for Russia.

As President Obama has signed an order to impose sanctions on sectors of the Russian economy, it looks like the next step may well be escalating sanctions.

The US and EU will want this to be one of those one-in-three times when such actions work.


Grimm night of entertainment

Grimm Tales premieres in east London basement

Little Red Riding Hood The audience moves with the cast through a maze of corridors and secret rooms

It has been the stuff of nightmares for children for centuries, big bad wolves, evil witches and magic. Now, writer Philip Pullman's collection of Grimm Fairy Tales has been adapted for an immersive theatre experience.

Once up on a time, a group of thespians gathered in their dark, subterranean lair plotting to thrill and scare any visiting townsfolk who dared descend into their dank and eerie chambers.

Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, Little Red Riding Hood - gruesome morality folktales that have chilled and inspired people for generations, originally collected and published by the Brothers Grimm in the 18th Century.

In 2012, Philip Pullman - the writer of the His Dark Materials trilogy, pulled some of the lesser known tales together in a new collection of Grimm Tales.

It is from that source that director Philip Wilson has drawn the material for a new immersive theatre experience in the bowels of Shoreditch Town Hall in east London.

Led down into the building's maze-like basement by Little Red Riding Hood, the audience passes phantom-like chandeliers of tattered wedding dresses and through dreamlike corridors lined with mirrors and cobwebbed clocks.

'Scruffy salvage'

How long did it take to turn a rather dusty basement into this fairytale setting?

"It was frighteningly quick actually," says director Wilson. "It's a bit like being on a movie set, things have been gathered for several weeks but, because it's a very busy venue we didn't have access until last Monday and we were performing by the Friday so it's been quite tricky."

The audience is invited to explore the labyrinthine location. Old cupboards and chests are overflowing with decaying headless dolls and ancient paintings glare down from gilded frames.

Wilson - former director at the Salisbury Playhouse says: "They all had to be created, the world we're in, the term I used is 'scruffy salvage' and the idea is that, a bit like Rapunzel in the tower, these characters have been down here for a long time and they've been going out at night gathering things from skips and they have found things which help them tell the stories".

The Big Bad Wolf The Big Bad Wolf is represented by an actor in a large fur pelt

So, a length of rope is used for Rapunzel's flowing locks, an elegantly tattered umbrella becomes a beautiful bird in The Juniper Tree and a length of garden hose is the snake in The Three Snake Leaves.

"There are no theatre lights, it's all about light bulbs and anglepoise lamps and chairs that we scrounged and found. We've been raiding junks shops and boot fairs for months to throw all this together," continues Wilson.

"The venue is atmospheric — magically lit by Howard Hudson, who embellishes its handsome decay," says Henry Hitching in his review for the Evening Standard. "But the decision to bill this as "immersive" theatre seems fanciful; though it's a promenade piece, we aren't welcome to participate," he says.

Once upon a time

Grimm Tales is not the first of Pullman's works to be adapted for the stage, In 2003, Nicholas Wright scripted the National Theatre's adaptation of His Dark Materials, directed by Nicholas Hytner.

Wilson says Pullman "was very interested but very sanguine", in regards to the Grimm production.

"We talked a lot and he liked what I wanted to do. The Grimm tales were always an aural tradition about storytelling. He did his own version and brought a little bit of himself to the texts. I've read them aloud and they are wonderful to read.

"Consciously, there is always a sense that you know you are being told a story, they all start with, 'Once, upon a time..."

The Juniper Tree The production uses scavenged materials as props

Lucinda Everett, writing in the Telegraph, says "sticking rigidly to Pullman's dark, witty text, the cast take their lead from the oral tradition of fairy tales, doing away with a narrator in favour of speaking the lines to one another. It is an ingenious move. The basement suddenly feels like a primitive dwelling, and the cast its inhabitants, acting out the tales for their own entertainment."

Gruesome events

The production doesn't mask the more gruesome events in some of the Grimm Tales. A child is decapitated by a wicked stepmother and eaten by his father, a brave soldier is buried alive with his dead sweetheart and a woman is crushed by a falling millstone.

That said, the night is open to children and adults alike.

"What's wonderful about Philip," says Wilson, "like Michael Morpurgo and JK Rowling, he's cross generational, he doesn't patronise children and there's much for adults to enjoy.

"We've said we recommend children over eight to come, with immersive theatre they're very, very close to the action, even if they know the actors are pretending, we did have a child who was a bit traumatized by the decapitation of a puppet.

"It's not gory but it's very there, there's no them and us, the audience are right there."

In his four-star review for What's On Stage, Michael Coveney says "the performance panders deliciously to the worst in all of us and proves once more that children's stories are best kept for adults".

Grimm Tales is on at Shoreditch Town Hall until 24 April.


VIDEO: The smart pen that spots mistakes

Media playback is unsupported on your device

The pen that spots mistakes as you write

21 March 2014 Last updated at 15:25 GMT

A pen which vibrates when it detects its owner making a mistake is to undergo testing in schools.

The Lernstift or "learning pen", does not require ink or special paper to work and uses an internal gyroscope to work out what is being written.

BBC Click's Dan Simmons reports.

Watch more clips on the Click website. If you are in the UK you can watch the whole programme on BBC iPlayer.


Why 'no make up selfies' raised £2m

Why the 'no make up selfies' campaign raised £2m

Selfie picture sent to CRUK

The 'selfie' has reached a new zenith this week, thanks to the "No Make Up Selfie for Cancer Awareness" campaign which has seen £2m raised for Cancer Research UK in the space of just a few days. But how did it happen?

The #nomakeupselfie started trending on Tuesday as women posted pictures of themselves without make up on Twitter and Facebook, and urged their friends to do the same.

Cancer awareness became the theme, selfie posters pledged donations to cancer charities and CRUK set up a text number to make donating even easier.

But the cancer charity did not kick-start the trend - it grew organically, making a huge impact on social media and getting attention in national newspapers and on radio and TV news.

So why did it go viral? Was it all about raising awareness and money for life-saving research?

No-one quite knows how the trend started. It may have been related to the Oscars selfie featuring a gaggle of gorgeous A-list actors which was retweeted endlessly following the film awards in early March.

Or it may have been a reaction to the negative comments directed towards 81-year-old actress Kim Novak following the same event.

People lined up to sympathise with her by posting pictures of themselves in (mostly) unflattering lights.

Cancer Research UK says thank you to donors Cancer Research UK staff celebrate the donations

With hundreds of thousands of donations, 826,000 likes on Facebook and 140,000 followers on Twitter, Cancer Research UK confessed to being "overwhelmed with donations and support".

But not everyone is behind the idea that women revealing their real face is something brave or altruistic.

Commentators have lined up to say that the campaign made cancer awareness all about vanity and emotion rather than about useful, practical action.

Dr Linda Gibson, senior lecturer in public health at Nottingham Trent University, says the success of the campaign shows that social media is a very powerful medium, particularly among young people, but there are dangers inherent in it too.

"This campaign has captured the imagination. Very rapid communication like this has never been faster in human history, but you have to be careful.

"You can lose the depth of message. When thinking of designing interventions using these media there can be unintended consequences."

Virgin cabin crew selfie Even a Virgin cabin crew join in the "no make up selfie" trend

The message may not be clear, but that can be a good thing because it forces people to ask "what's this about?", she says.

The problem comes when people believe they are doing something important when really their actions are not changing anything.

In that case, aren't we just using social media to clear our consciences, just by sending a selfie?

The money raised - 80p in every £1 donated goes to cancer research - suggests this is more than just an exercise in self promotion.

Images sent to CRUK demonstrate that people want show their solidarity with cancer sufferers, and pay tribute to friends and family who have died from the disease.

The Institute of Fundraising says combining popular trends with fundraising is a great way to reach young and untapped audiences. Men are now getting on board by posting selfies of themselves wearing make-up, this time in a bid to raise awareness of men's cancers.

Use of celebrity trends also helps to target those that wouldn't necessarily think about the charity or the cause otherwise, it adds. And there have been plenty of big names posting their selfies this week.

But perhaps there is more to the success of this selfie campaign.

"Maybe it's about how women feel about themselves, and their private and public faces," says Dr Gibson.

"The image of women in the media can be so artificial and constructed that body image often becomes an issue.

"This is almost an act of rebellion."


VIDEO: One very long night on Twitter

Media playback is unsupported on your device

As it happened: Turkey's long night on Twitter

21 March 2014 Last updated at 21:29 GMT

Turkey is one of the world's most active countries on social media. So what happens when Twitter is blocked there? Millions of tweets from Turkey, that's what.

Turkey's Prime Minister said late on Thursday that he wanted to "wipe out" Twitter using new laws, and soon after users in Turkey reported that they couldn't access the site. This led to a deluge of tweets being posted via proxy servers and SMS throughout the night.

#BBCtrending looks back over Turkish Twitter activity from dusk on Thursday to dawn on Friday, and traces the key moments in the story.

Video created by Benjamin Zand .


VIDEO: Migrants rescued off Sicilian coast

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Italian Navy rescue thousands of migrants

21 March 2014 Last updated at 21:51 GMT

The Italian navy says more than 4,000 migrants have been rescued from overcrowded boats in the Mediterranean Sea south of Sicily in the past four days.

On Thursday more than 230 people, who were packed onto a rubber dinghy, were picked up near the island of Lampedusa.

Our Rome Correspondent Alan Johnston reports.


VIDEO: Turks voice defiance over Twitter ban

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Turks defiant in the face of Twitter ban

21 March 2014 Last updated at 22:53 GMT

Some 2.5 million tweets were posted within three hours of Twitter getting blocked in Turkey.

Just before midnight on Thursday, over 10 million users started wondering why they could not access the site.

The reason soon became clear, as users who managed to access Twitter via workarounds started sharing screenshots of what appeared to be a statement by Turkey's telecommunications regulator.

James Reynolds reports.


VIDEO: Singer defends skin whitening cream

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Singer Dencia defends promotion of skin whitening cream

21 March 2014 Last updated at 19:29 GMT

Cameroonian pop singer Dencia has defended her promotion of a skin whitening cream called Whitenicious, which critics have branded an ''abomination'' and ''irresponsible''.

Speaking on Focus on Africa, she insisted the cream was not about skin lightening, but about tackling ''hyper-pigmentation''.


VIDEO: The village shop in a vending machine

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Inventor turns vending machine into a village shop

21 March 2014 Last updated at 16:05 GMT

An inventor has built a giant vending machine, as a way of helping rural communities that have lost their village shop.

The first one has just been installed in a pub car park at Clifton, near Ashbourne in Derbyshire and there are already plans to place them in other villages in the area.

Inventor Peter Fox told BBC News how it works.


VIDEO: Michelle Obama meets Chinese leader

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Michelle Obama meets Chinese President Xi Jinping

22 March 2014 Last updated at 01:46 GMT

US first lady Michelle Obama has met with Chinese President Xi Jinping on the first day of her week-long tour of the Asian nation.

The formal meeting occurred in a state guesthouse and included Mr Xi's wife, Peng Liyuan, along with Mrs Obama's two daughters and mother.

"I cherish my sound working relationship and personal friendship I already established with your husband," Mr Xi reportedly said, as reported by US media.

Mrs Obama's trip has also included a tour of a school where she played table tennis with a student and tried her hand at calligraphy.

Mrs Obama, who is making history as the first US first lady to visit China independently, is said to be focusing on student exchanges and education during her trip.

Catharinah Moh reports.